Disney's Old Key West Restaurants List (A Resorts Gal Guide)

If you’re planning a stay at Disney’s Old Key West, you probably already know you’ll have a few more amenities in your room than at a regular resort. At the very least, a deluxe studio will offer a small sink, toaster oven, and microwave. One-bedroom and larger units will have a full-size kitchen. That said, it’s your vacation, so you’ll still want to be aware of the dining options at the resort.

Below, we’ve compiled a list of the restaurants at Disney’s Old Key West. We’ve added the regular operating hours, links to menus, and photos of a few things we’ve tried. Admittedly, Old Key West doesn’t have a ton of restaurants. But between the in-room amenities and proximity to Disney Springs (where there are over 60 dining options), we think you can do just fine. (It’s no secret how much we adore this resort’s charm.)

a scenic view of Hospitality House at Disney's Old Key West

Old Key West Restaurants List

Here is a list of the dining options at Disney’s Old Key West.

Good’s Food To-Go
Gurgling Suitcase Libations and Spirits
Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks
Olivia’s Cafe

Below, we’ll preview details for each location.

a lake with buildings at Disney's Old Key West

Good’s Food To Go

Good’s Food To Go is the resort’s quick-service restaurant. It sits between the resort’s lobby and Community Hall. Good’s is a unique quick service because it doesn’t have an indoor dining location. Disney’s Old Key West is the only resort that doesn’t have a fast, casual restaurant with interior seating.

Location: Hospitality House
Hours: 7:00 a.m. until 10:00 p.m.
Disney: Menu with Prices

a sign that says Good's Food To Go, Old Key West's quick service restaurant

However, Good’s Food To Go does have a substantial menu with breakfast, lunch, and dinner items. You can even order Mickey waffles for breakfast. The menu offers the usual burgers, chicken nuggets, hot dogs, salads, sandwiches, and kids’ meals for lunch and dinner. This location also accepts mobile orders and has a separate mobile order pick-up window.

Related: Mobile Orders at Disney World

Good's Food To Go Walk Up Quick Service Restaurant Disney's Old Key West

A covered area offers a beverage refill station with coffee, tea, and water. Those who purchase Rapid Fill mugs can refill their beverages at this location, which is also convenient to the resort’s feature pool area.

a fountain beverage refill machine at Old Key West

While Old Key West’s quick service lacks an indoor dining area, it offers an excellent place to enjoy a meal outdoors. This long row of picnic tables with umbrellas offers a scenic setting.

a row of picnic tables with striped umbrellas at Disney's Old Key West

Gurgling Suitcase Libations and Spirits

The Gurgling Suitcase sits next to Good’s Food To Go. This hole-in-the-wall (literally) location is a walk-up bar with limited seating. But don’t be surprised if it’s packed. It’s an Old Key West favorite.

Location: Hospitality House
Hours: 10:30 a.m. until 11:00 p.m.
Disney: Menu with Prices

The Gurgling Suitcase serves appetizers, cocktails, beer, and wine. Appetizers are available daily until 10:00 p.m. They have hushpuppies, shrimp cocktails, Conch fritters, and deep-fried pickles with ranch dressing. This isn’t the worst place to pick up a few items to enjoy by the pool! This location serves Disney’s standard cocktail menu, which is available at most all pool bars and lounges. But they have a few specialty drinks specific to the resort, like the Pineapple Mule, Key West Freeze, and Turtle Krawl.

sign that says Gurgling Suitcase Libations and Spirits

Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks

If you’re familiar with Disney’s Old Key West, you know it’s spread over a decent area with four pools. The Sandcastle Pool is the feature pool at Hospitality House near Good’s Food To Go and The Gurgling Suitcase. However, since the resort is so large, one of the secondary pools has its own quick service. You’ll find Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks at the Old Turtle Pond Road pool.

Location: Turtle Pond Pool
Hours: 11:30 a.m. to 7:00 p.m.
Disney: Menu with Prices

Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks offers items like cheese and pepperoni pizza, sandwiches, ice cream novelties, Mickey pretzels, and kids’ meals. It also offers a variety of beverages, cocktails, and beer selections. A small room with a beverage refill station is around the corner from the order window, where guests can refill Rapid Fill mugs.

Olivia’s Cafe

Olivia’s Cafe is the only table service restaurant at Disney’s Old Key West. We’ve enjoyed several meals here and always look forward to returning.

Location: Hospitality House
Breakfast and Lunch Hours: 7:30 a.m. to 2:00 p.m.
Dinner: 5:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m.
Disney: Menu with Prices

Olivia’s Cafe is located in the center of Hospitality House, across the outdoor walkway from the lobby and immediately next to Conch Flats General Store. If you’re visiting the resort to dine at Olivia’s, you’ll want to exit the bus at the Hospitality House bus stop.

Guests can dine inside or outside. We’ve enjoyed breakfast on the outdoor patio, but we usually have lunch inside if it’s hot.

an outdoor dining area for a restaurant at Disney's Old Key West

I ordered buttermilk pancakes with bacon and grits instead of eggs on our last stay. Everything was excellent, but those grits are so good! They are an Olivia’s Cafe specialty.

an order of buttermilk pancakes and grits

We’ve tried the Southernmost buttermilk fried chicken. It’s country-fried and comes topped with gravy.

an order of Southernmost fried chicken from Olivia's Cafe at Old Key West

The signature bacon cheeseburger is another nice entree. Sometimes you just want a cheeseburger.

a cheeseburger and fries from a restaurant at Disney's Old Key West

Dining Options Near Old Key West

Since Old Key West is in the Disney Springs Resort area, guests can take a bus or the DVC ferryboat from the resort to Disney Springs. The boat is a pleasant way to get to and from Disney Springs. It drops guests off at the Marketplace. You can board another boat from the Disney Springs boat dock to Port Orleans French Quarter and/or Riverside Resorts. You can also walk or boat to Disney’s Saratoga Springs from the Marketplace boat dock.

If you take the bus to Disney Springs from Old Key West, you’ll get dropped off at Town Center. Disney Springs is a large place, to minimize walking you might prefer to take a boat to Disney Springs and then take a bus back to the resort or vice versa. If you’re visiting the venue for a dining reservation, it’s good to know where you’re going. For example, if you had reservations at Summer House on the Lake, you would have an exceptionally long walk from the boat dock. So you might prefer to take the bus to Disney Springs and then take a leisurely stroll to the boat dock after dinner for your return trip.

For some of our favorites, you might enjoy our list of the best restaurants at Disney Springs. It includes a variety of quick service and table service locations.

Final Thoughts

Overall, Disney’s Old Key West is a serene resort with sufficient dining on-site and seemingly endless options a short boat or bus ride way. If you have a kitchen during your stay, you can also place or pick up a grocery order to supplement eating out for every meal during your vacation. For more on this resort, you might enjoy our Resorts Gal Guide to Disney’s Old Key West.

Are you considering the Disney Dining Plan?

Make sure to check out our guide to understanding the Disney Dining Plan and sign up below to get a free copy of the Resorts Gal Restaurant Finder.

In the Comments

We hope you found this dining guide for Disney’s Old Key West helpful. What do you think of these options? Leave your thoughts below in the comments.